Philip K. Jones on Baker Street Beat

A new review of my book Baker Street Beat popped up on Amazon.com the other day. I was delighted to see that the author was Philip K. Jones. Mr. Jones has compiled a data base of more than 9,000 Sherlockian pastiches, paradodies, and related fiction, so he knows whereof he speaks. As Matt Laffey put it recently on his Always 1895 blog, "When the king of pastiches gives you a good Amazon review, you run with it!" So here it is:

This is a collection of personal reminiscences, early fiction and literary commentary by a long-time Sherlockian. It contains a personal history of one man's lifelong fascination with the Canon. It also presents glimpses of other Sherlockians, their personalities and foibles, their whimsies and their exploits. From my point of view, it provides the added benefit of listing the earlier publications of the items presented. This make their entry into the database of Sherlockian pastiches, parodies and related fiction all the easier for me.

The first two items are personal expositions of the author's fascination with the world of Sherlock Holmes; a history of his Canonical reading and a description of a pilgrimage to the Reichenbach Falls. Both items are unique and are also typical of the commentaries of other devotees of the Canon. The general trend of the discussions actually describes the process many hobbyists go through in picking up a lifelong interest, especially a literary one.

There are two other items of literary commentary included. The first is a discussion of the mysteries of Doctor Thorndyke, created by R. Austin Freeman, and the influences of Sherlock Holmes evident in those tales. This is most interesting. I have collected and read the Thorndyke mysteries for years and I was aware of some of those influences, but the author's depth of detail was most impressive. The final literary commentary discusses writing a Sherlockian pastiche, using articles by various Sherlockians and examples of effective and ineffective methods. I found myself torn on reading this segment, for I feel that the author has missed an important aspect of the Canon and I am in the process of writing an article of my own on this very subject. In any case, this item should give `newbies' an idea of what depths experienced Sherlockians can plumb in their efforts to understand the fascination they have with Sherlock Holmes.

The author has included four of his own efforts at writing fiction in this collection. The first is an early pastiche, "The Peculiar Persecution of John Vincent Harden." This is an interesting effort to relate one of the "Untold Tales," those cited in the Canon, but never told by Watson. This was one of two such tales cited in "The Solitary Cyclist." There have been at least ten other efforts to tell this tale, but then some of the "Untold Tales" have been written scores of times. The second tale, "The Adventure of the Amateur Players," is a mystery surrounding the presentation of a play about "Sherlock Holmes" by an amateur acting group, many of whom are Sherlockian hobbyists.

The final two items presented are scripts for radio programs. The first, "The Wrong Cab," stars a real life detective in a quasi-Sherlockian adventure with odd results. The second is "The Adventure of the Speckled Band" and it presents a Canonical tale in format for a radio broadcast. I am unfamiliar with the requirements of such compositions and cannot judge the effectiveness of these efforts.

This book concludes with a bibliography that includes all the sources mentioned in the various items. It is not exhaustive, but it does provide a useful starting point for persons new to the world of Sherlockian fixation. All in all, this is an interesting book with items worth re-reading. It gives a good picture of the progress of the Sherlockian affliction, but offers no real promise of a cure for the disease.

Mr. Jones's review gave Baker Street Beat a very respectable four stars. The average of all 17 reveiws for the book on Amazon.com remains at five stars.

A New Review

Joe Revill has posted on nice review of Baker Street Beat on his blog, A Case of Witchcraft, named for his book of the same title. Here's what he says:

Dan Andriacco’s “Baker Street Beat” is a slim volume of Holmesian writings of various kinds. The stand-out piece here is the excellent pastiche, “The Peculiar Persecution of John Vincent Harden”, which is very much in the manner of the original stories. I also enjoyed the time-travelling play “The Wrong Cab”, in which a modern American private eye becomes Holmes’s partner in a grisly mystery set in the Chamber of Horrors; and “Reichenbach Pilgrimage”, which gives a good account of what there is to be seen at the second most famous place in the Canon.

I have to take issue with Dan over his essay on “Writing the Holmes Pastiche”, however, since his rules would disallow any Holmesian fiction not written from Dr. Watson’s point of view, containing real historical characters, and having the word “Case” in the title! They are good enough rules if one is trying to produce an exact imitation of the original stories, I suppose; but some of us want to do something new with the beloved characters. For my part, I thought that it would be interesting to see Holmes at work without Watson, but instead trying to build a working partnership with someone very different, to whom he could show another side of his personality; and I think that it works rather well, in my novel, when circumstances oblige him to team up with the young Aleister Crowley.

Two positive reviews in one!

Felicia Carparelli, author of Murder in the Library, has posted a wonderful review of Baker Street Beat at her murder blog. In it, she manages the amazing feat of reviewing my book and Sir Paul McCarney's current concert tour in the same post. If that doesn't make you want to read it, nothing will!

Summer-time Reading

The latest review of Baker Street Beat on Amazon.com says:

Dan's book of essays, short stories, and radio dramas is just the ticket for summer time reading.

Thanks to all who have written a review and/or "liked" Baker Street Beat on Amazon.com. If you have read the book and not written a review, please do so here.

The First Review is In

The first review of Baker Street Beat (the book) has been posted on Amazon.com. It's brief but very welcome. "Lee" writes:

Great fun to read Andriacco's scribblings, especially the pastiche.
Only complaint is that it's way too short!
Publish some more . . .

What a nice complaint! And it came with a four-star recommendation.

If you have read the book and liked it, please post a review on Amazon.com. If you have read the book and didn't like it, please keep that a secret! And if you haven't didn't read the book, please do.